It is ironic that every year Pakistan has to Come under pressure of for a small amount of 1.5 billion. Pakistan's budget cannot be balanced by taxation alone. It can only be balanced when the country stops spending scarce foreign exchange on goods it is capable of producing itself. Every year, billions of dollars leave the country to import finished cars and car parts, medicines and their raw materials, electronic components, television parts, air-conditioning equipment, and countless engineering goods. Each such import is not merely a purchase; it is a job created abroad, a factory kept idle at home, and pressure on the rupee. When the rupee falls, the cost of debt servicing, petrol, and imported inputs rises, and the budget goes out of balance again. Import substitution, therefore, is not an old-fashioned slogan. It is the most direct and practical way to balance the budget, save foreign exchange, create employment, and build a taxable industrial base.

The idea is simple. First, replace a finished import with local production for the domestic market. Second, improve quality and cost until the same product can be exported. Third, use the foreign exchange saved and earned to stabilise the economy. Pakistan had started on the same path in the 1960s. Private industrial houses were investing in engineering, electrical goods, light manufacturing, and vendor industries. Skills were developing, workshops were growing, and the foundation for a broad import-substitution base was being laid.

That momentum was broken by nationalisation under Zulfikar Ali Bhutto. Beginning on 2 January 1972, the government took over 31 key industrial units and placed iron and steel, basic metals, heavy engineering, heavy electrical, and motor vehicle assembly and manufacture under state control. The stated purpose was to promote economic democracy, end concentration of wealth in a few families, and put Pakistan on the path of socialist progress. The result, however, was the opposite of what was intended for industry. Private investors lost confidence. They stopped investing in new plants, stopped expanding existing units, and in many cases shifted capital into trade and real estate. State-managed units, run without commercial discipline and subject to political interference, became inefficient, overstaffed, and loss-making. The development of the engineering and import-substitution sector, which needs continuous private investment, risk-taking, and technical upgrading, came to a halt. A generation of industrial learning was lost.

The sector regenerated in the Zia era. From 1978 onwards, the government moved toward denationalisation, deregulation, and greater reliance on private enterprise. Confidence slowly returned. Small and medium workshops, auto vendors, electrical goods makers, and engineering units began to reappear in Karachi, Lahore, Gujranwala, Sialkot, and Faisalabad. The private sector again became the engine of industrial growth. The lesson of that period remains valid: industry grows when policy is stable, ownership is secure, and the entrepreneur is trusted.

That recovery was then undermined during the period of Shaukat Aziz as Prime Minister, when liberalisation was pursued without adequate preparation for local industry. Tariffs on finished goods were cut sharply, and cheap imports, especially from China, flooded the market. For the consumer, this appeared as lower prices. For the local manufacturer, it was destruction. A Pakistani factory was paying high electricity and gas charges, high interest rates, and duties on raw materials and machinery. Against it stood a finished imported product, produced at massive scale in China, often with subsidised energy and export incentives, entering Pakistan at low or zero duty. Local industry could not compete on such an uneven field. Many units closed. The country sat back, consumed imports, and lost both jobs and skills. The trade deficit widened, foreign debt increased, and the budget became permanently dependent on borrowing and on IMF programmes.

Today, the sector is re-emerging, not because conditions have become easy, but because necessity has forced it. The evidence is already visible. The auto parts industry now comprises more than 1,200 companies, supports about 1.5 million jobs, and contributes about $1.8 billion annually through import substitution, supplying components worth Rs700 billion to assemblers. Mobile phone assembly has expanded dramatically, with local plants producing 20.08 million handsets in January to September 2026 compared with only 2.85 million commercially imported units. The government is now targeting up to 50 percent domestic value addition in mobile manufacturing. The proposed Auto Policy 2026-31 talks of raising parts exports to $700 million by 2030-31.

The scope for further development is great, and the sectors are exactly the right ones. In automobiles, there is scope for engine parts, suspension, brakes, wiring harnesses, plastic mouldings, sheet metal parts, batteries, tyres, and increasingly electronic car parts such as sensors, lighting, and EV components. In medicines, there is scope for formulations, active pharmaceutical ingredients, packaging, and surgical instruments, building on an existing base to meet international quality standards. In electronics, there is scope for printed circuit boards, chargers, power supplies, inverters, solar inverters, and UPS systems. In television parts, there is scope for LED panel assembly, power boards, backlights, and cabinets. In air-conditioning, there is scope for compressors, coils, fans, thermostats, and sheet-metal work. The logic in each case is the same: start with the labour-intensive and simpler part, master quality and cost, then move up to the more complex component.

The way forward requires government support, but support of the right kind. It does not need charity. It needs a level playing field, like Lego blocks that fit together: policy, energy, finance, and skills. First, tariff discipline. Duty should be low on raw materials and machinery that Pakistan does not make, and protective but time-bound on finished goods that Pakistan does make. Policy must not change every three years. Investors will not invest in dies, moulds, and plants if the next policy suddenly makes imports cheaper. Second, energy at competitive rates. No industry can compete with China if electricity and gas are two to three times more expensive. Export-oriented and import-substituting units must be given a predictable, competitive tariff. Third, finance for machinery and tooling. A parts maker's biggest cost is not labour but the die, mould, and testing equipment. Long-term loans at single-digit rates for tooling and laboratories are essential. Fourth, clusters and common facilities. Small firms cannot each afford heat treatment, electroplating, PCB prototyping, calibration, and testing labs. Vendor clusters in Karachi, Lahore, Gujranwala, Sialkot, and Faisalabad with shared facilities will lower cost and raise quality. Fifth, linkage with assemblers. Assemblers of cars, motorcycles, air-conditioners, televisions, and phones must be required to increase local content year by year and to help vendors with drawings, technology, and quality. Sixth, skills and standards. Polytechnics must be revived for CNC machining, mould-making, electronics, refrigeration, and quality control. Institutions like PCSIR, universities, and industry must jointly reverse-engineer the import list. Seventh, from substitution to export. Protection that never ends creates laziness and high prices. The rule should be clear: five years of protection, then the unit must export 10 to 15 percent of production. Export discipline forces quality, cost control, and innovation. For manpower, more and more skill development institutions were created. There is no coordination between the federal government and the provinces on taxation finance and industry. The result is provinces bulge up their revenue Keep on pausing Tex on industry without realizing that it will become unviable and die.

In one line, the message is this: protect the infant, but do not protect the inefficient forever. Give local industry cheap energy, stable policy, and fair tariffs, and it will balance the budget by saving dollars, creating jobs, widening the tax base, and finally turning Pakistan from a nation of importers into a nation of makers. (sources open media)