The Mecca Agreement continues to attract considerable attention, particularly in the context of rising tensions involving Iran. Questions are being raised about its implications for Pakistan and whether its commitments could eventually place Islamabad in a difficult position vis-à-vis its neighbor and longstanding friend, Iran. Pakistan has repeatedly maintained that the agreement is not directed against Iran but is intended to promote regional stability, collective security and peace. This assurance is important and deserves to be viewed in its proper perspective. Pakistan has every reason to support stability in the region, particularly when conflict could have serious consequences for the entire Muslim world. However, there is an important aspect of the agreement that deserves closer examination: the provision that an attack on one signatory would be considered an attack on all is explained in Article 2 out of 16 articles. Let us see what Article 2 says." An externally originating armed attack against any of the "Parties" shall be considered an attack against all the "Parties." If one of the "Parties" is subjected to an armed attack or military aggression by another country or group of countries, the "Parties" shall immediately assist the attacked "Party," making full use of all means of mutual assistance that they can provide to one another. For this purpose, to enable the exercise of the right of self-defense recognized by Article 51 of the Charter of the United Nations, the "Parties" shall determine the scope and nature of the support to be provided following an objective assessment of the assistance required, and shall cooperate within the limits of their available resources, including military means and capabilities. At first glance, this appears to be a strong collective defence commitment. But its practical application raises some interesting questions. The wording, however, should not be interpreted as an automatic commitment to enter every conflict involving a signatory.

There is a distinction between a full-scale external military attack threatening a country's sovereignty and territorial integrity, and limited cross-border incidents, missile exchanges or attacks by non-state groups. This distinction is particularly relevant in the case of Yemen's Houthi movement. We have already witnessed Houthi attacks on Saudi territory and critical installations. Yet these incidents have not resulted in a collective military response by Pakistan and Turkey under the agreement. Pakistan has stated that no military response was discussed following the Houthi attacks. This raises an important question: where exactly does an incident end and an attack warranting collective defence begin? This is perhaps the practical catch in the agreement. There may be no immediate occasion when the holy city of Makkah itself is threatened, but Saudi territory and strategic installations can face sporadic attacks as they are facing and minor skirmishes. Would every such incident automatically invoke the collective defence clause? Clearly, the answer requires careful interpretation and mutual understanding among the three signatories. For Pakistan, the situation is particularly delicate. Iran is not merely a neighboring country; it is a longstanding friend with whom Pakistan shares historical, religious, cultural and economic ties. At the same time, Saudi Arabia occupies a special place in the hearts of Pakistanis, while Turkey is an important strategic partner with whom Pakistan enjoys friendly relations. Pakistan cannot afford to alienate Iran, nor can it disregard its commitments to Saudi Arabia and Turkey. Should a major military confrontation involving Iran and Saudi Arabia emerge, Islamabad could find itself in one of the most difficult diplomatic and strategic situations in its history.

The challenge would be to honor its commitments without becoming a party to a wider regional war. A conflict involving Iran would also carry serious implications for Pakistan's western border, internal security, economy and regional stability. Opening another front would be against Pakistan's fundamental national interests. The real strength of the Mecca Agreement should lie in its ability to prevent war rather than provide a framework for entering one. Its collective security provisions should serve as a deterrent against aggression, not as an invitation to expand regional conflicts. Pakistan must continue to use its diplomatic influence to reassure Tehran that the agreement is defensive and not designed to isolate or threaten Iran. Equally, Saudi Arabia and Turkey should recognize the importance of Pakistan's special relationship with its neighbor. The distinction between an armed attack and the nature of the collective response remains important.

The United States also has an important role to play. Rather than allowing tensions to escalate, Washington should give serious consideration to the seven-point peace proposal reportedly put forward by Iran and pursue negotiations that address the legitimate security concerns of all parties. Dialogue, guarantees and mutual restraint remain the only sustainable alternatives to another devastating regional confrontation. Ultimately, the Mecca Agreement should be remembered as an initiative for collective security, Muslim unity and regional peace. Its success will not be measured by how readily its signatories can mobilize against an adversary, but by how effectively they can prevent a war. Pakistan must stand by its commitments, but it must also stand for peace. These two responsibilities should never become contradictory. Pakistan's wisest course is to use its relationships with Washington, Riyadh, Ankara and Tehran to bring the parties to the negotiating table. Preventing war must be the priority. The success of the Makkah Accord should ultimately be measured not by its military strength, but by its ability to preserve peace and prevent another devastating regional conflict.

One factual qualification: the Houthi attacks have raised questions about the pact's application, but it would be too categorical to say they are legally excluded from its provisions. The distinction between an armed attack and the nature of the collective response remains important.